|
E-mail this page to a friend!
Social Security Investment Accounts, Indexing in
Bush Budget
Reform ideas that never caught on in 2006 are back in
the 2007 budget
Feb. 6, 2006 – There were so many things grabbing
the public's and media's attention in the $2.77 trillion federal budget
for FY 2007 presented yesterday, that many senior citizens may have
missed that the President has put private investment accounts and the
indexing of benefits (determining payments by need) for Social Security
back on the table and in the budget.
(Note: See Social Security budget below news
report.)
| |
Related Stories |
|
| |
Social Security Reform Has Withered but Program Still Needs
Help
Author Nancy Altman says the problem is not
that hard to solve
Feb. 1, 2005 – Social Security Reform, a buzz
phrase for the last few years, seems to have come and gone on the agenda
of President George W. Bush, as indicated by the lack of support in his
State of the Union last night. There is, however, a financial problem for
the program somewhere out there in the future. Nancy J. Altman, an
author and former assistant to Alan Greenspan, says in the following
opinion piece that the program is still vital and financial security is
not that difficult to achieve.
Click to
read her opinion...
Social Security Not in Top 10 Resolutions by White
House Aging Conference
Conference ends for another ten years, will send
these recommendations to President, Congress
Dec. 15, 2005 - The 2005 White House Conference on
Aging (WHCoA) officially closed yesterday, with delegates calling for
renewal of the Older Americans Act within six months and putting a
priority for the President and Congress on a strategy for long-term
care; enhanced public transportation; and, stronger and improved
Medicaid and Medicare programs. Interestingly, there was nothing about
Social Security in their top ten resolutions.
Read more...
Read more on
Social Security or
Social Security Reform |
|
The creation of private investment accounts for
younger workers was the major domestic proposal for the President in
2005, but the idea met hostile opposition by most senior citizen
advocacy groups and a cool reception in Congress. The concern expressed
by most seniors was that the investment accounts would put their
retirement benefits at risk. The President tried to overcome these fears
by assuring those already drawing Social Security that they would not
see any changes.
The Social Security Administration, in an
explanation of their budget posted online yesterday, said, "Social
Security is sound for today’s seniors and for those nearing retirement,
but it needs to be fixed for younger workers."
The statement said the President is committed to
"strengthening the Social Security system" and has put forward three
goals for any reforms:
● strengthen the safety net for future
generations;
● protect those who depend on Social Security; and
● offer every American a chance to experience the opportunity of
ownership through voluntary personal retirement accounts.
"Under the President’s approach, Social Security
would include voluntary personal accounts funded by a portion of
workers’ payroll taxes," according to Social Security.
Here is how they say the personal accounts will
work:
"The accounts will be funded through the Social
Security payroll tax. In the first year of the accounts, contributions
will be capped at four percent of Social Security taxable earnings, up
to a $1,100 limit in 2010, increasing by $100 each year through 2016."
So, a younger worker, rather than pay all of his
Social Security payroll tax to the government's Social Security fund,
could designate up to $1,100 be put in a private investment account.
The President, says Social Security, has also
embraced the idea of indexing the future benefits of the highest wage
workers to inflation while providing for a higher rate of benefit growth
for lower-wage workers.
This measure, they say, would significantly
contribute to the solvency of the system.
Here is how they say indexing will work:
"By adjusting the way benefits are calculated,
progressive indexing would eliminate nearly 70 percent of annual cash
shortfalls by the end of the Social Security Trustees’ long-range (75
year) valuation period, trending towards greater improvement thereafter.
"Because progressive indexing would index benefits
for lower-wage workers to wage growth, which generally grows faster than
inflation, benefits would grow faster than the poverty level. This will
keep a greater portion of future seniors out of poverty than today.
There were no details on exactly how much senior
would receive not a definitive description of "the highest wage
workers," whose benefits would be indexed to inflation.
Referring to the current system's "empty promises,"
the statement said, "By adopting progressive indexing and allowing young
workers to create voluntary personal retirement accounts within the
Social Security system, the President’s recommendations would provide
future seniors with real money.
"Indexing benefits partially to inflation rather
than wages allows the Government to save significant sums in future
decades, money that would be used to maintain faster benefit growth for
low-income seniors."
The statement concluded saying, "Without Social
Security reform, benefits for future seniors will have to be cut about
30 percent across-the-board."
In discussing the problems with the current system,
Social Security says:
"Social Security is sound for today’s seniors and
for those nearing retirement, but it needs to be fixed for younger
workers. Social Security today operates on what is known as a
“pay-as-you-go” basis, in which current worker payroll taxes are used
immediately to pay for the benefits of current retirees and other
beneficiaries.
"In 1950, there were about 16 workers for every
retiree. Today, there are slightly more than three workers for every
beneficiary. By the time today’s 20-year-olds retire, that number will
drop to two workers for every beneficiary.
"Furthermore, people are living longer than when
the system was created. As the baby boom generation begins retiring in
2008, there will be a dramatic rise in the number of retirees, putting
added strain on the system.
"In 2017, the Social Security system will collect
less in taxes than it pays in benefits and will shift into a permanent
cash deficit that will grow every year. In 2041, Social Security will
exhaust its Trust Fund assets. If Social Security’s problems are left
unresolved, today’s young workers will see their benefits sharply and
suddenly cut, their children’s payroll taxes raised, or both."
Social Security Budget Document in pdf –
Click Here
Below is the Budget Proposal for Social Security
It shows actual 2005, 2006, 2007 budget
and change 06 to 07
Social
Security Administration
(In millions of dollars)
|
|
2005 Actual |
2006 Estimate |
2007 Estimate |
Change 06-07 |
|
Discretionary Budget Authority: |
|
|
|
|
|
Limitation on
Administrative Expenses (LAE) Base1 |
8,733 |
9,109 |
9,496 |
387 |
|
Office of the
Inspector General. |
90 |
91 |
96 |
5 |
|
Research and
Development |
28 |
20 |
20 |
0 |
|
Subtotal,
Discretionary budget authority |
8,851 |
9,220 |
9,612 |
392 |
|
All other |
8 |
1 |
1 |
0 |
|
Total,
Discretionary budget authority |
8,859 |
9,219 |
9,611 |
392 |
|
Total,
Discretionary outlays |
9,023 |
9,265 |
9,541 |
276 |
|
Mandatory
Outlays: |
|
|
|
0 |
|
Old-age,
Survivors, and Disability Insurance |
518,772 |
550,594 |
581,428 |
30,834 |
|
Supplemental
Security Income |
38,258 |
38,011 |
36,915 |
-1,096 |
|
Special
Benefits for Certain World War II Veterans |
11 |
12 |
11 |
-1 |
|
Offsetting
Collections |
3,034 |
3,508 |
3,275 |
-233 |
|
Legislative
proposals |
— |
— |
162 |
162 |
|
Total,
Mandatory outlays |
554,007 |
585,109 |
614,917 |
29,808 |
|
Total, Outlays |
563,030 |
594,374 |
624,458 |
30,084 |
1
The LAE account includes funding from the Hospital Insurance and
Supplementary Medical Insurance trust funds for services that support
the Medicare program, including implementation of Medicare Reform.
AGENCY-SPECIFIC GOALS
SSA sets goals to provide high-quality service,
which is reflected in the Agency’s commitment to increase productivity,
timeliness, and accuracy in processing applications for disability
benefits. With this Budget, SSA expects to achieve the performance
targets outlined in the accompanying table.
|
Goal |
2005
Actual |
2006
Goal |
2007
Goal |
|
Productivity: |
|
|
|
|
Disability Decisions, Per Worker Per Year1 |
260 |
262 |
276 |
|
SSA
Hearings Decisions, Per Worker Per Year |
102 |
104 |
106 |
|
Timeliness (in days): |
|
|
|
|
Average
Processing Time for Initial Disability Claims |
93 |
93 |
93 |
|
Average
Processing Time for Hearing Decisions |
443 |
467 |
467 |
|
Accuracy: |
|
|
|
|
Disability Determination Services Accuracy Rate |
NA |
97% |
97% |
|
Accuracy
Rate for Hearing Decisions |
NA |
90% |
90% |
1 In 2005, an SSA
worker on average made 260 disability decisions in that year. The higher
number in a given year, the greater the productivity.
Click here to Search SeniorJournal.com for more on
this subject
Click to More Senior News on the
Front Page
Copyright: SeniorJournal.com |